ata ATA Meal and Rest Break Petition blog Denham Amendment dot Featured Post FMCSA Meal and Rest break Politics Regulations trucker safety trucking industry

FMCSA controversy and the flip flop dilemma

The Federal Motor Service Safety Administration (FMCSA) is an agency in the United States Department of Transportation that regulates the U.S. trucking business and is  the lead government company chargeable for regulating and providing security oversight of economic motor automobiles (CMVs).

FMCSA’s mission is to scale back crashes, injuries, and fatalities involving giant vans and buses.

United States Department of Transportation

Now I don’t find out about you, but I consider we should have the ability to trust in those that are in control of creating and implementing laws, especially with regards to my life and the lives of others who rely upon these legal guidelines for his or her safety and livelihood.

I also consider that a government agency ought to keep their objective and integrity at all value.  Selections must be based mostly on safety without favor or bias.

Again, FMCSA is to to scale back crashes, injuries, and fatalities involving giant vans and buses.

  • When the DOT was established on October 15, 1966, the ICC’s regulatory authority over truck and bus security was transferred to DOT, delegated to FHWA and designated the Office of Motor Service Security.
  • In 2000, Congress established FMCSA as a stand-alone DOT agency pursuant to the Motor Service Safety Enchancment Act of 1999.

It’s imperative that if you find yourself an company of the Federal Authorities you need to remain consistent and not be biased in the direction of anybody group or entity, but fairly remain loyal to your function of security.

The FMCSA stakeholders embrace Federal, State, and local enforcement businesses, the motor service business, safety teams, and organized labor on efforts to scale back bus and truck-related crashes.

The ATA does not characterize Professional Truck Drivers

Many truckers consider that there are rules and laws that have closely leaned in favor of the appeals of the American Trucking Affiliation (ATA).  One such example is that of the digital logging system (ELD)   which is a bone of rivalry for a lot of truckers.
Another instance is FMCSA granting exemption request to C.R. England so that a learner’s permit holder who has documentation of passing the CDL expertise check does not have to have a CDL driver in the front seat. New Prime and CRST additionally have been granted exemption.

The ATA will give the impression that they characterize the whole trucking business. They don’t.  The ATA doesn’t characterize the views of most professional truck drivers.

The Massive Flip Flop-  ATA Meal and Rest Break Preemption Petition

Lately there has been a huge controversy relating to the ATA Petitions for Willpower of Preemption: California Meal and Rest Break Rules. submitted to FMCSA  in October of 2018 and then granted after only 3 months on Dec 21, 2018.

Regardless of dropping in Courts and Congress FMCSA grants ATA petition

The rationale for the  Meal and Rest Break Petition controversy

Since 2015, the American Trucking Associations, and the Western States Trucking Association, along with the 50 ATA-affiliated state trucking associations, the National Personal Truck Council, the Truckload Carriers Association and the Truck Renting and Leasing Association , have been lobbying Lawmakers to include the Denham Modification in major items of Legislation so as to Preempt States Right. They failed.

1. The ATA Petition was submitted to the FMCSA after 4 years of dropping in courts and Congress as they tried to Preempt State Labors which permit truckers 30 minute meal breaks and 10 min paid meal breaks. These states additionally require carriers to pay drivers for all non driving duties, together with detention time.

So, after motor carriers misplaced in the courts, the battle to preempt state rights went to Congress, as the well-known Denham Modification, designed to deny truckers meal & rest breaks and pay for all working time, was struck down  5 occasions.
Denham Amendment defeated in FAA bill BUT it’s not over- ATA sends petition to FMCSA

ATA seeks FMCSA approval to Preempt state legal guidelines which shield trucker wages

2  The First Flip Flop
Though the MRB petition was granted, The FMCSA  had denied this similar petition 10 years in the past, nevertheless, a decade later and totally different appointments inside the agency, that they had a change of heart” in the direction of the ATA.
Although the petition was granted, there was no point out that drivers pending courtroom instances can be affected by their determination to grant the petition.  Thus the choice was not retroactive.

2008 Rejection of the ATA Petition:
ACTION: Discover of rejection of petition for preemption.

2018 FMCSA Granting of ATA Petition
FMCSA Order; grant of petition for willpower of preemption.

three  Then, the FMCSA despatched out an array of complicated statements. On Jan seventh 2019 FMCSA confirming that their willpower of the Meal and Relaxation Break Petition doesn’t have retroactive impact on driver pending courtroom instances.
On January 18, 2019, the FMCSA lawyer states that FMCSA is giving the retroactivity situation additional consideration

But then, on March 22, 2019, FMCSA decides that sure, all pending courtroom selections can be retroactive, even when those lawsuits by drivers have been acted upon previous to the December 21st granting of the ATA petition.
THIS was one other flip flop, as initially the FMCSA determination DID NOT embrace pending courtroom instances by drivers to be affected. So what modified their mind?

You’ll be able to read the comedy of errors your self here
California Meal & Relaxation Update: March 2019

Last FMCSA Determination of March 22, 2019
FMCSA Legal Opinion on Applicability of Preemption Determinations to Pending Lawsuits

FMCSA Conclusion

“For all of the reasons discussed herein, FMCSA’s legal opinion is that an FMCSA preemption decision under Section 31141 precludes courts from granting relief pursuant to the preempted State law or regulation at any time following issuance of the decision, regardless of whether the conduct underlying the lawsuit occurred before or after the decision was issued, and regardless of whether the lawsuit was filed before or after the decision was issued.”

March 22, 2019
Charles J. Fromm
Deputy Chief Counsel

1 This opinion is issued by the Deputy Chief Counsel as a result of the Chief Counsel is recused from the specific preemption willpower that gave rise to the question addressed herein.

Battle of Interest

Jim Mullen- Chief Counsel-FMCSA

This conclusion by the FMCSA was imagined to have been decided by the Chief Counsel Jim Mullen, nevertheless, he recused himself from the determining opinion.  Might it’s as a result of he worked for Werner Enterprise for therefore a few years, or perhaps because he helps Motor Carriers in his own business? We don’t know, nevertheless, we do know that the opinion was then written by Charles J. Fromm, Deputy Chief Counsel at Federal Motor Service Security Administration.
But who’s Charles J Fromm? No work history, pictures, or profile on FMCSA web site.

four  The most important controversy of all consists of not solely flip flop selections of the ATA Meal and Relaxation Break Petitions of 2008 and 2018, and then the later  flip flop of deciding if courtroom instances have been to be retroactive or not, however a query of Battle of Interest.

The Chief Counsel of FMCSA, Jim Mullen, an appointed position, held positions at Werner Enterprises at numerous levels for 10 years; Government Vice President and Common Counsel and Vice President and Common Counsel of Litigation.
In accordance with his LinkedIn profile, Mr Mullen also continues to operate his Consulting firm as he stays as Chief Counsel of FMCSA.

His Consulting agency, Jim Mullen Consulting, the place he resides as president.
Provide skilled providers and advice to giant motor carriers and transportation trade associations in the areas of federal regulatory and legislative authorities relations advocacy, authorized issues, and danger and claims management. With over a decade of expertise as the Common Counsel and Government Vice President of 1 of the nation’s largest motor carriers, Mullen provides a wide range of expertise in transportation related areas of advocacy in Washington DC, legal and compliance matters, and danger and claims management.

The fact that Mr. Mullen recused himself and had Charles J. Fromm signal the Meal and Rest Break Opinion, give little to no satisfaction, since we don’t even know who Mr. Charles J. Fromm is, the place he comes from, or who he labored for previous to being Deputy Chief Counsel at FMCSA.

Charles J. Fromm- Deputy Chief Counsel- FMCSA

So the question I’d wish to ask is, just what number of ATA members or prior MEGA service staff work at the FMCSA? What affect have they got on determination making? However the most concerning query of all is, how can an agency representing the complete trucking business determine rules and laws affecting drivers, if these making the selections could possibly be biased towards the motor carriers, the employers of those drivers?

Simply observe, drivers Meal and Rest Break instances are still being heard in the courts and the courts will determine if the FMCSA opinions hold water or not.
But I’m positive they’ll think about the following.

First the FMCSA rejects the ATA petition in 2008. Then they grant it 2018. FMCSA lawyer then  writes that the new MRB guidelines will not be retroactive in response to an inquiry. Then they are saying they are reconsidering if they’ll be retroactive. Then the Chief Counsel recuses himself. Then the Deputy Chief Counsel says it is retroactive.

I don’t assume courts should defer to incoherent company opinions written by interested events. It’s referred to as separation of powers for a purpose.

© 2019, Allen Smith. All rights reserved.

Technorati Tags: ata, ATA Meal and Rest Break Petition, Denham Modification, FMCSA, Meal and Rest break, trucker security, trucking business



Security Ideas for Driving Alongside Tractor-Trailers